All Classical Radio James Depreist

A 21st-century reboot: Seattle Opera’s gender-bent ‘Alcina’

SO staged the Handel opera with six singers (including one countertenor), modern set design, and haute couture costuming.


Vanessa Goikoetxea (Alcina) in "Alcina" at Seattle Opera. Photo by Sunny Martini.
Vanessa Goikoetxea (Alcina) in “Alcina” at Seattle Opera. Photo by Sunny Martini.

SEATTLE – George Frideric Handel’s operas don’t amass a lot of stage time in the United States. Seattle Opera has presented only four in its 60-year existence.

The fourth, which continues through Oct. 28 at SO’s McCaw Hall, is Alcina–and what a playfully sexy choice it was, cleverly stage-directed by British-born Tim Albery, known for his taut, poetic presentations. The production should convince the opera world to give Handel a 21st-century reboot.  

The music of Handel’s operas is neither complex nor alienating, but the singers are hard to find. Alcina requires, as do many of Handel’s pieces, a countertenor, whose part in the old days was sung by castrati (boys castrated before puberty to provide high voices because women and girls were banned from singing in the church or onstage) and for whom Handel consistently and enthusiastically composed. Castrati were a big deal in Handel’s time, many of them period rock stars. Since the 19th century when the gelding practice was banned, though it was never lawful, countertenors have been few and far between. Usually the countertenor parts, often considered “trouser” roles, are filled by mezzo-sopranos.

Randall Scotting (Ruggiero) in "Alcina" at Seattle Opera. Photo by Sunny Martini.
Randall Scotting (Ruggiero) in “Alcina” at Seattle Opera. Photo by Sunny Martini.

But this time a 6-foot-3-inch Viking of a man Randall Scotting undertook the powerful countertenor part of Ruggiero and filled out a cast of six wonderful singers, including two sopranos, two mezzos, a tenor and himself, who sang in an uncanny falsetto-like upper register, certainly a new listening experience for many opera goers. Forget baritones, basses, or a chorus. Handel likes to write for the higher voices. Contrary to the Baroque tendency to be overblown, ornamental and over- the-top, this opera was performed by a sleek cast of six, often onstage at once.The singers didn’t perform ensemble pieces (until the end, and a bit at the beginning), but they did sing one beautiful solo da capo aria after another, prompting a response with another beautiful three-part aria. Certainly the singers used plenty of vocal ornamentation, a Baroque singing technique that uses many sounds for one syllable (melisma), and provides a way to show off a good voice.

The story, however, is Baroque in all ways of excess. Sorceress Alcina (soprano Vanessa Goikoetxea) — think Circe —  seduces Ruggiero, who washes up on her shore, separated from his wife, Bradamante (mezzo-soprano Ginger Costa-Jackson). Bradamante disguises herself as a man (her brother) and sets out to find her lost husband Ruggiero, with Melissa (mezzo Nina Yoshida Nelsen) the “good” rather nondescript sorcerer — perhaps she was supposed to seem invisible. Melissa is a role that Handel designed for a bass, and it was gender-swapped in this production. She sings the opera’s lowest note, an E below middle C.

Nina Yoshida Nelsen (Melissa) and Ginger Costa-Jackson (Bradamante) in "Alcina" at Seattle Opera. Photo by Philip Newton.
Nina Yoshida Nelsen (Melissa) and Ginger Costa-Jackson (Bradamante) in “Alcina” at Seattle Opera. Photo by Philip Newton.

When they arrive at Alcina’s place, Alcina and Ruggiero are deeply in lust (maybe in love) and Morgana (soprano Sharleen Joynt), Alcina’s extroverted and bored sister, tries to seduce Bradamante, whom she thinks is a man. Sex roles are confused and gender-bent, and the besotted Ruggiero takes forever to recognize his true wife. As well, he is under the threat of being turned into a beast if he displeases Alcina. A rug with the head of a bearlike beast lies among the chairs to remind him, and as the opera progresses, his glances at the furry rug become more fearful.

As for realizing Bradamante is his wife, that comes in the second act, when she strips down to her bustier, following other characters who have thrown off layers of clothes while singing in awkward positions. Perhaps the slow striptease shows their vulnerability but it also keeps alive our attention and anticipation in this 2 hour-40 minute performance – not that everyone disrobes at the same time. Each new striptease interjects humor, of which this show has plenty. Alcina, defeated in her efforts to continue to enchant Ruggiero, toward the opera’s end, crawls around covered in the beast rug, stripped bare to expose the defeated emotions that Handel so masterfully tries to show. During these moments we realize the singers are agile magicians at producing gorgeous music whether engaging in sex, seducing, arguing, crawling under chairs, or throwing off a sock as charmingly illustrated by Oronte (Tacoma tenor John Marzana), Morgana’s spurned husband who endures the rest of the opera in his two-piece modest black underwear.


All Classical Radio James Depreist

Sharleen Joynt (Morgana) and John Marzano (Oronte) in "Alcina" at Seattle Opera. Photo by Sunny Martini.
Sharleen Joynt (Morgana) and John Marzano (Oronte) in “Alcina” at Seattle Opera. Photo by Sunny Martini.

Alcina, the star — though, really,  this was an ensemble piece that doled out big parts to each of the singers — had a remarkably huge and vibrant voice. You could have heard her miles away, and her soaring soprano could be either fierce or tender with colors in between. Her voice produced a wide range of emotions with each aria. She kept our hearts beating, especially in the second act.

The visual vibe was un-Baroque. Dual scenic and costume designer Hannah Clark created both in contemporary style, sorceress aside, while Ian William Galloway designed the moody, muted and undistracting video. A number of multi-purpose Mid-Century-Modern-ish teal and turquoise chairs were scattered around the stage, designed for arguments, love or sex, and the large onstage screen flashed video behind the set that made the audience feel as if it were riding waves or stepping into the surrounding jungle. The staging concept was stunningly pared down, studded by onstage lights that rose and fell. 

Then there were the costumes. Soprano Joynt, who sang Morgana, the sexually preoccupied sister of sorceress Alcina, wore a cocktail dress that Dolce & Gabbana could have designed, accessorized with a pair of patent leather ballet flats, while Alcina moved with utter grace in long classic mermaid dresses —  pale, flared and modest in the first act when she is in control; black and “diamond”-studded in the second act that emphasized her elegance, despair and aging.

Ginger Costa-Jackson (Bradamante) and Sharleen Joynt (Morgana) in "Alcina" at Seattle Opera. Photo by Philip Newton.
Ginger Costa-Jackson (Bradamante) and Sharleen Joynt (Morgana) in “Alcina” at Seattle Opera. Photo by Philip Newton.

There was so much to like about this production. Christine Brandes, a former opera singer, conducted the small orchestra with the continuo group of harpsichord, theorbo and baroque guitar. Most of the singers and major production people were making their SO debuts in this opera that premiered in 1735 in London, and I’m sure members of that talented crew will be back.

At the rate Seattle Opera has presented Handel works, it will be about 350 years before it is able to perform all of Handel’s 42 operas, said SO’s Lokela Alexander Minami, who gave a pre-show lecture. Too bad we won’t have enough time on Earth to see them all.

Sharleen Joynt (Morgana) in "Alcina" at Seattle Opera. Photo by Philip Newton.
Sharleen Joynt (Morgana) in “Alcina” at Seattle Opera. Photo by Philip Newton.

Be part of our
growing success

Join our Stronger Together Campaign and help ensure a thriving creative community. Your support powers our mission to enhance accessibility, expand content, and unify arts groups across the region.

Together we can make a difference. Give today, knowing a donation that supports our work also benefits countless other organizations. When we are stronger, our entire cultural community is stronger.

Donate Today

Photo Joe Cantrell

Angela Allen writes about the arts, especially opera, jazz, chamber music, and photography. Since 1984, she has contributed regularly to online and print publications, including Oregon ArtsWatch, The Columbian, The San Diego Union-Tribune, Willamette Week, The Oregonian, among others. She teaches photography and creative writing to Oregon students, and in 2009, served as Fishtrap’s Eastern Oregon Writer-in-Residence. A published poet and photographer, she was elected to the Music Critics Association of North America’s executive board and is a recipient of an NEA-Columbia Journalism grant. She earned an M.A. in journalism from University of Oregon in 1984, and 30 years later received her MFA in Creative Writing/Poetry from Pacific Lutheran University. She lives in Portland with her scientist husband and often unwieldy garden. Contact Angela Allen through her website.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

CMNW Summer Festival SB FIXED #1, TP, Top
Salem World Beat SB FIXED #2
Astoria Open Studios Tour
Lake Oswego Festival of Arts
NW Dance Project
OCCA Monthly
Maryhill Museum of Art
PAM 12 Month
PSU College of the Arts
Oregon Cultural Trust
Oregon ArtsWatch holder
We do this work for you.

Give to our GROW FUND.