MYS Oregon to Iberia

Astor’s great and messy quest


In the early years of the 19th century, John Jacob Astor, a German immigrant who’d already become wealthy through the fur trade and Manhattan real estate, gambled big on a grand vision. His plan was to establish an “emporium” near the mouth of the Columbia River — a geographic feature only recently known to Europeans and Eastern settlers — supported by fur-trapping posts along its tributaries. This would allow him to dominate the Pacific Northwest’s vast supply of one of that era’s most valuable resources. His company would then be able to initiate a lucrative global shipping network, trading in not just furs but Chinese tea and European manufactured goods. Flush with early-American idealism, he further hoped to set the stage for a democratic government in the region, a political and cultural sister to the fledgling United States, then still clustered on the continent’s eastern edge.

Jimmy Garcia as Pierre Dorion and Leif Norby as Robert McClellan with members of the cast of “Astoria: Part Two.” Photo: Patrick Weishampel/

To these ends, Astor, in 1810, sent two expeditionary parties toward the Columbia, one by sea around Cape Horn, the other overland, heading out from St. Louis along the trail blazed a few years earlier by Lewis and Clark. The harrowing, often deadly, adventures of these groups is vividly told in Peter Stark’s 2014 best-seller Astoria: John Jacob Astor and Thomas Jefferson’s Lost Pacific Empire, a Story of Wealth, Ambition and Survival, and now in Chris Coleman’s sweeping theatrical adaptation for Portland Center Stage. Astoria: Part One premiered last season; Astoria: Part Two is on the boards at The Armory through Feb. 18, with a few bonus performances of the first installment sprinkled through the schedule.

SPOILER ALERT: Astor fails.

If this were a piece of historical adventure fiction, the demand for a shapely dramatic arc would leave us with plucky pioneers cheerfully proceeding with the work of Manifest Destiny. But the truth is that Astor’s initial American-run mercantile settlement falls prey to resource depletion, geographical remoteness, uncertain relations with surrounding tribes, and unforeseen geopolitical shifts (namely, the War of 1812). In hindsight, we can see that far too many things would have had to go just right. Astor and his soon-to-be bedraggled hirelings simply could not foresee what we might now call the “unknown knowns.”

Front: Leif Norby as Robert McClellan and DeLanna Studi as Marie Dorion.
Rear (L-R): Christopher Hirsh and Michael Morrow Hammack. Photo: Patrick Weishampel/

But though Astor’s commercial venture on the Columbia runs aground, his loftier dreams of democratic expansion and pan-Pacific trade eventually take flight; it’s his men who hap upon the route that becomes the Oregon Trail, and the rest is, of course, (better-known) history.

Success, don’t ya know, is a matter of expectations. And that principle holds true for the theatrical Astoria, too.

During his long tenure at the helm of Portland Center Stage (which ends at the close of this season, when he leaves for a similar post in Denver), Coleman has distinguished himself as a director and an administrator, but on occasion has shown to be a skillful writer as well, most notably in the 2012 adaptation Shakespeare’s Amazing ‘Cymbeline,’ which improbably yet deftly recast the Bard’s complicated romantic adventure for six actors and a blues pianist/narrator.


PCS Clyde’s

Adapting Stark’s book of popular history no doubt presented much greater challenges: locales that ricochet from Manhattan to the Columbia and even to Hawaii, with all manner of treacherous seas and mountain ranges in between; multiple time frames for the sea-going party, the overland party and Astor back East; a large cast of characters with complicated roles and relationships; and most of all, a narrative scope that presents loads of gripping action yet also demands ongoing contextual framing and frequent exposition. There’s just no way this play could deliver what good contemporary theater usually offers: absorbing, fine-grained examination of human emotion and behavior through tightly focused circumstances, yielding poetic allusions to The Way We Live.

From left: Jeremy Aggers, Jimmy Garcia, DeLanna Studi, Christopher Hirsh, Chris Murray and Ben Rosenblatt. Photo: Patrick Weishampel/

Compared to drawing-room realism or more imaginative constructs, Astoria, of necessity, sometimes feels a little stilted, more staged civics lesson than classic “well-made play.”  Characters regularly address the audience in formal, almost declamatory tones to set the scenes or fill in bits of the copious narrative. Part Two, taken on its own, can be a bit hard to follow at moments, as the various members of the overland party, scattered by a combination of calamity and piecemeal strategic adjustments, straggle in and out of the story.

Yet there’s so much the piece does so well that it earns admiration for its ambition, affection for its sheer verve, and, yes, patience with its mammoth running time.

Once again in Part Two, the show benefits greatly from Portland stalwart Leif Norby, as convincing in rectitude and urgency as Astor as he is laid-back and backwoods as one of the frontiersmen. Gavin Hoffman shines again as the louche and headstrong Scotsman Duncan McDougall, and in fact nearly everyone in the cast of 17 has fine moments. Shawn Fagan (replaced here by the more steadfast-seeming Douglas Dickerman), who brought such sensitivity to the earnest dithering of overland party leader William Price Hunt, is missed; but there’s fresh pleasure in the work of Rafael Untalan, an addition to Part Two as the friendly, slyly witty Chinook named Concomly. Then there are the estimable contributions of Tony Cisek’s grandly rustic and versatile scenic design, a wealth of colorful costumes by Alex Wren Meadows and Toni-Leslie James, plenty of rousing songs beautifully arranged by Rick Lewis, and half a world of disparate dialects coached to unlikely credibility by Mary McDonald-Lewis.

Members of the cast of “Astoria: Part Two.” Photo: Patrick Weishampel/

But what’s most impressive — and like the eventual success of the American Astoria experiment, most resonant in the long term — is the way Coleman has heightened many of the thematic elements embedded in Stark’s historical account.

The remark made early in both installments — that had things not gone quite so, those now living west of the Rockies and north of San Francisco would be Brits or possibly Russians — might seem an only vaguely interesting “what if,” a reminder that in 1810 Manifest Destiny was far from manifest or destined. Yet at times Astoria plays like an examination of the unpredictability of history. At others it seems a broader treatise on the fraught nature of human endeavor and the vagaries of human character.

Threaded through, too, are Coleman’s clear political sensitivities — to the worth and variety of native cultures; to the strength and savvy of the few female characters; to the tensions between Western “settlement ” and a holistic environment … Coleman makes vivid so many themes and implications that the piece might have been called (with a nod to Portland novelist Whitney Otto) How to Make an American Quilt.


PCS Clyde’s

But of course, Astoria it is. And well worth a visit.


Astoria: Part Two continues through Feb. 18 at Portland Center Stage at The Armory, with a few performances of Astoria: Part One, which premiered a year ago, also available. Ticket and schedule information here.


Read Marty Hughley’s review of Astoria: Part One from January 2017.


Be part of our
growing success

Join our Stronger Together Campaign and help ensure a thriving creative community. Your support powers our mission to enhance accessibility, expand content, and unify arts groups across the region.

Together we can make a difference. Give today, knowing a donation that supports our work also benefits countless other organizations. When we are stronger, our entire cultural community is stronger.

Donate Today

Photo Joe Cantrell


Marty Hughley is a Portland journalist who writes about theater, dance, music and culture. His honors have included a National Arts Journalism Program fellowship at the University of Georgia, a fellowship at the NEA Arts Journalism Institute in Theater and Musical Theater at the University of Southern California, and first-place awards for arts reporting in the Society of Professional Journalists Pacific Northwest Excellence in Journalism Competitions. In 2013 he was inducted into the Oregon Music Hall of Fame for his contributions to the industry. A Portland native, Hughley studied history at Portland State University, worked at the alternative newsweekly Willamette Week in the late 1980s as pop music critic and arts editor, then spent nearly a quarter century at The Oregonian as a reporter, feature writer and critic. His recent freelance work has appeared in Oregon ArtsWatch, Artslandia and the Oregon Humanities magazine. He lives with his cat, and dies a little with each new setback to the Trail Blazers.


One Response

  1. Well, I tried to share this on my own FB page, sigh, and failed. Welcome back, Marty, and thank you for both a review and a meditation, offering much food for thought, as well as your usual excellent writing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

PCS Clyde’s
MYS Oregon to Iberia
Profile Theatre Orange Sky
Mt Tabor Art Walk
OCCA Monthly
PNCA MFA Exhibition
NW Dance Project
Maryhill Museum of Art
PAM 12 Month
Pacific Maritime HC Prosperity
PSU College of the Arts
Oregon Cultural Trust
We do this work for you.

Give to our GROW FUND.